I think you need to take into account that these matches don’t happen in a bubble. UT vs HBK was in the middle of a really mundane WM25. Yes that one match was great, but in the stadium environment you loose the noise of the audience so it doesn’t sound like the crowd is as engaged it should have.
And nowadays it would be hard to rate any WWE PPV match five stars because any viewer is worn down by the length of the shows. It’s why a hot NXT or NJPW show is more likely to elevate a great match to five stars rather than take away.
Hopefully Wai gets more followers and more people pay attention to POST from this. I saw several responses to Jericho in support of Wai, not to mention Wai’s own response.