I also think it’s worth realizing that Punk never wanted to be in AEW to begin with.
Allegedly he reached out to WWE in summer 2021 to gauge interest and was shot down.
Previous to that he hadn’t seriously taken AEW’s offers up.
I think within the year of him being there, he went from thinking he could steer the ship and was upset when he found resistance to his ways of doing things.
By All Out 2022, he clearly wanted out. He went nuclear at the press conference.
By January 2023, he was allegedly exploring options to get out of his deal and come to WWE.
When Collision was announced, he continually threw up road blocks and caused drama. It’s been well reported that he was the one speaking to media (SRS, Meltzer, Mike Johnson, and Nick Hausman have all outed him from one degree to another). He’s terminally online and has always been one to try and stir the pot.
By the time he came back this summer, if it wasn’t one thing it would have been another. By the time All In happened, it was unavoidable.
Even if TK had pulled everyone into a meeting and tried to push forward, Punk’s behavior and personality clearly would have found another way to be unhappy.
Punk’s mind was likely made up with two factors:
- When The Elite re-signed.
- When Tony went on record stating that if anything happened to him, Bryan Danielson would be called upon to run things.
Those two factors made it clear to Punk that he’d never have the kind of power he believed he would within AEW.
He wanted out. He got his way out. He’s gone. I’m personally happy the last few weeks of AEW has clearly felt like a refocused product that is trying to lean into what brought them to the dance in the first place.
And now, Punk is playing the role of WWE Superstar perfectly, and is happy to be “home”.