I see the case for Orange Cassidy as the ol’ reliable on seemingly every Dynamite. But for my tastes, he has been too much of an average thing. Same with Mox. I like him more than OC, but he’s also done too much mediocre stuff to make my list.
WWE candidates would be Rhodes, Rollins, Zayn and the Bloodline (or Reigns or Jey Uso individually). But none of them have the complete body of work to touch MJF’s 2023.
(AEW and WWE only, for the record. Only promotions I watch regularly.)
I’ll always respect everyone’s opinions , but clearly the answer is MJF. Not saying his ring work was bad in the indys, but he stepped up his game, in ring super quick. And the mic work, ridiculous!!
My pick would be MJF, but a Cody is a close second as he has been money since his return. I also want to give honourable mention to Adam Cole, Jey Uso and Sami Zayn.
I like in ring, but I’m more of a story guy and nobody has told better stories then these guys this year.
We all know Ospreay is the shit, in ring. But, the promo he cut in front Jericho, during the contract signing. Ospreay killed it.
For the future, AEW really needs to start pushing Daniel Garcia. To me, he has that it factor, where, for some reason, Ricky Starks and Sammy Guevara isn’t connecting.
So far this year here is who has the most matches:
Kenny Omega - 9
MJF - 8
Darby Allin - 8
Young Bucks - 8
Jon Moxley - 7
Roman Reigns - 6
FTR - 5
Cody Rhodes - 5
Kevin Owens - 5
Jey Uso - 5
So my conclusion is that Kenny Omega has had the most really good matches this year including a likely match of the year contender in Omega vs Osprey.
But I don’t know if I can think of more than 1 or 2 memorable promos by Omega. For week-to-week entertainment value with either a great promo or a great match each week I would name MJF as the wrestler of the year so far in AEW and Roman Reigns in WWE.
Forgot about Gunther. But MJF still gets my nod because he’s being asked to carry a promotion. Gunther is just delivering bangers left and right… great matches, but a lot of guys do that.
Anyone watch a lot of WrestleUniverse or Japanese wrestling? I gotta vote Kenoh. He’s one of the only high points of NOAH, he won titles in Dragon Gate and All Japan, and he main evented a Wrestle Kingdom against Naito and ALL TOGETHER teaming with Okada. And his matches are always killer. Even if he has flat opponents, his character of ‘always aggrieved’ can make those matches fun.
His matches against Kaito Kiyomiya on the New Years card and the N1 final against Go Shiozaki were among the best matches of the year as well. Definitely NOAH’s best performer in 2023.
I actually didn’t catch it this year, opting to follow the 5 Star Grand Prix instead with my spare time. Only watched the finals, knowing that it would be an excellent match.
I’m a little behind but have really enjoyed it overall! My top matches I’ve seen so far are Wagner vs Shiozaki, Soya vs Nakajima, Anzai vs Soya, and Kenoh vs Yoshiaki, very cool to me to see such a recent Open the Dream Gate Champion being in the N1!